Operations Research
Operations Research
Welcome to the Operations Research tab. Here you will find one framework, of many, to map researchable program questions. Additionally, there is a list of internationally vetted research questions, as well as a table to track on-going research and documentation. Questions, actual research, and documentation are linked to the framework.
- Global iCCM Operations Research Agenda*
- Research & Documentation Table
- Meeting Minutes
Front-line health workers
- What is the effect on the performance of CHWs when management of one or more disease is added to the existing responsibility?
- Which is the effect of iCCM in improving adherence to RDT test results and rational use of drugs?
- What are all of the roles that community-based health workers currently play apart from managing the 3 top killers, such as community-based surveillance, immunization, management of cholera, preparing families for emergencies/outbreaks?
- Are CHWs able to assess, classify, and treat various illnesses under integrated CCM?
- What are the best ways to improve and sustain performance of CHWs?
- What are the costs and performance of different training methods for (illiterate/literate) CHWs?
- What are the best methods for evaluating the quality of services provided by CHW?
- What is the optimal number of CHWs to give near universal coverage to a given geographic area?
- What are the roles of community-based volunteers (Red Cross, etc.) and how do they link to CHWs and formal health systems?
- How do community-based volunteers fill gaps and can they take off some of the burden from CHWs?
- What are the best ways of supervising CHWs?
- Which factors increase recruitment and reduce attrition?
- Which methods of remuneration/incentivization are effective and sustainable?
- How can mobile telecommunication technology (mHealth) improve the quality of care and supervision of CHWs?
Implementation
- What is the cost and cost-effectiveness of iCCM?
- What are appropriate methods for cost recovery and financing?
- How can effective coverage be achieved by CCM (equity, community effectiveness, etc.)?
- Which is the role of community monitoring and local accountability in iCCM implementation?
- How can the private sector become involved in delivering iCCM and what role can iCCM play in improving the quality of care in the private and informal sectors?
- How acceptable are CHWs to the health system, and how can CCM requirements for drugs, supplies, supervision, etc. be met? Which are the minimum and optimal health systems supports for iCCM to be effective?
- What are health system effects of CCM on referral patterns to and caseload and case mix at first level health facilities?
- What is the effect of iCCM on antibiotic resistance?
- What is the impact of iCCM on drug use and therapeutic outcomes in the community?
- How best can CCM be implemented in fragile or emergency settings? How it can be streamlined, accelerated, targeted, and monitored to reach emergency affected communities or improve resilience? How quickly can CHWs be trained and mobilized in an emergency?
Management of illness
- How can available tools (RDTs, clinical signs, timers, drugs, pulse oximeters, etc.) be combined into clinical algorithms?
- What is the algorithm performance in different epidemiologic and health system contexts?
- Can mHealth applications play a role in improving the adherence of CHWs to clinical diagnostic and treatment algorithms?
- What is the appropriate duration of antibiotic treatment of WHO-defined non-severe pneumonia in African settings?
- Can CHWs treat WHO-defined severe pneumonia in the community?
- How can age-dose regimens for different drugs be harmonized, and what are the effects on treatment of different packaging techniques?
- What is the impact of pre-referral drugs on clinical outcomes of children with severe disease?
- What treatment options are effective and safe in settings where referral is not possible?
- What is the most appropriate antibiotic for treatment of pneumonia?
- What is the most appropriate formulation of antibiotics?
Families and caregivers
- Do family members recognize the disease and promptly seek care?
- What are the elements that facilitate family members to utilize CCM services?
- Do family members follow treatment recommendations properly?
- How can timely referral completion be facilitated for severely ill children?
- Can mHealth applications be used to help family members recognize disease, seek care, and adhere to treatment recommendations?
- How does prescription of multiple medicines for multiple diseases (e.g., malaria & pneumonia) impact on adherence?
- What key knowledge and tools can be provided by CHWs to families so they can care for themselves at home in the event of an emergency (home-care) in the event that services are not accessible? How can families be best prepared for emergencies and outbreaks?
Impact
- What is the impact of iCCM on health and survival of children?
- Does iCCM lead to increased penetration in terms of reaching the poor? (effective coverage)
- What is the impact of iCCM on building community and health system resilience (e.g., coping with an emergency)?
*New additions to the list of research priorities are presented in italics.

| # | Title | CCM Priority Global Research Question(s) | Principle Investigator(s) | Settings and Time-Frame | Design | Donor | Presentation (dates) or Publication (citation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Feasibility and Effectiveness of an Integrated Community Health Worker – Trained Traditional Birth Attendant Team on the Delivery and Use of Treatments for Infections among Children 0-59 Months of Age in Lufwanyama District, Copperbelt Province, Zambia |
27 and 31 |
Kojo Yeboah-Antwi, David Marsh |
Lufwanyama, Zambia 2010-2012 |
Before-after HH survey to measure use of interventions; longitudinal measures of teaming, the domains of which informed by formative research; summative FGD and KII to explore acceptability of teaming |
USAID (partially funded); Crown Family Philanphropies (pending) |
|
| 2 | “Zambino” – A Programmable Young Infant Mannequin for Training Frontline Health Workers to Assess Respiratory Rate and Chest In-drawing |
3 and 4 |
Nick Guerina, David Marsh, Karen Waltens-perger |
Lufwanyama, Zambia 2010-2012 |
Compare the effect of Zambino-supplemented training to standard training in imparting skills in pneumonia case management |
Rejected by MCHIP; Crown Family Philanthropies (pending); Laerdal (?) |
|
| 3 | Access to Case Management for Childhood Illness: Worse Than We Thought |
6 |
Tanya Guenther, Salim Sadruddin, David Marsh, Tiyese Chimuna… |
Lufwanyama, Zambia; Malawi; and perhaps Mali 2010 |
Measuring geographic, temporal, seasonal, cultural, and security barriers plus availability of case management and drugs in communities supposedly within MoH-defined access |
Nested within CIDA and CS-25 |
Presentation: Montreux HSR 11/14/10 |
| 4 | Cluster Randomized Trial of Community Case Management of Severe Pneumonia with Oral Amoxicillin in Children 2-59 Months of Age |
21 |
Salim Sadruddin, Abdul Bari, Shamim Qazi, Amanullah Khan… |
District Haripur, Pakistan 2007-2010 |
Cluster randomized trial to compare the effect of treatment of severe pneumonia with amoxicillin by Lady Health Workers vs current standard of giving 1st dose by LHWs and referral to health facility |
WHO |
Publication: Manuscript ready for submission to Lancet
|
| 5 | Cost of treating severe pneumonia by Community Health Workers at household level |
10 |
Shehzad Shafqat, Shamim Qazi, Salim Sadruddin, Abdul Bari…. |
District Haripur, Pakistan 2009-2010 |
Compare the cost (direct medical, direct non medical and indirect due to lost productivity and travel time) of treatment of severe pneumonia at home by LHWs to diagnosis, administration of 1st dose and referral to a health facility. |
Edinburgh School of Public Health through CHERG |
Publication: Manuscript to be ready by March 31
|
| 6 | Effect of new supervisory approaches on quality of care, service utilization and CHW motivation |
3 and 7 |
Seydou Doumbia, SC (Salim Sadruddin, Tanya Guenther) JHU and UNICEF… |
Two districts each in Malawi and Mali Oct 2010- Sept 2013 |
The study will compare a new supervision approach to the current system. The study will focus specifically on evaluating the effect of enhanced supervision on 1) quality of care, 2) utilization of services, and 3) CHW motivation. If possible, the cost and benefit of enhance strategy will be assessed. |
Submitted to WHO-TDR -Rejected |
|
| 7 | Effectiveness of video based competency training for CHWs |
4 |
Salim Sadruddin, Janani Vijayaraghavan, Charles Ocan, Tanya Guenther, David Marsh |
Mvolo county in South Sudan Dec 2010- June 2011 |
Compare the effect of video-taped training conducted in non medical setting on trainee competence to training in a health facility involving live clinical cases. Will measure competencies post test and persistence over time. |
Nested within CIDA |
|
| # | Title | CCM Priority Global Research Question(s) | Principle Investigator(s) | Settings and Time-Frame | Design | Donor | Presentation (dates) or Publication (citation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Feasibility and Effectiveness of an Integrated Community Health Worker – Trained Traditional Birth Attendant Team on the Delivery and Use of Treatments for Infections among Children 0-59 Months of Age in Lufwanyama District, Copperbelt Province, Zambia |
27 & 31 |
Kojo Yeboah-Antwi, David Marsh |
Lufwanyama, Zambia 2010-2012 |
Before-after HH survey to measure use of interventions; longitudinal measures of teaming, the domains of which informed by formative research; summative FGD and KII to explore acceptability of teaming |
USAID and Crown Family Philanphropies |
|
| 2 | “Zambino” – A Programmable Young Infant Mannequin for Training Frontline Health Workers to Assess Respiratory Rate and Chest In-drawing |
3 & 4 |
David Marsh, Karen Waltens-perger |
Lufwanyama, Zambia 2010-2012 |
Compare the effect of Zambino-supplemented training to standard training in imparting skills in pneumonia case management |
Rejected by MCHIP; LOI to BMGF from PATH |
|
| 3 | Access to Case Management for Childhood Illness: Worse Than We Thought |
6 |
Tanya Guenther, Salim Sadruddin, David Marsh, Tiyese Chimuna… |
Lufwanyama, Zambia; Malawi; and perhaps Mali 2010 |
Measuring geographic, temporal, seasonal, cultural, and security barriers plus availability of case management and drugs in communities supposedly within MoH-defined access |
Nested within CIDA and CS-25 |
Presentation: Montreux HSR 11/14/10 |
| 4 | Cluster Randomized Trial of Community Case Management of Severe Pneumonia with Oral Amoxicillin in Children 2-59 Months of Age |
21 |
Salim Sadruddin, Abdul Bari, Shamim Qazi, Amanullah Khan… |
District Haripur, Pakistan 2007-2010 |
Cluster randomized trial to compare the effect of treatment of severe pneumonia with amoxicillin by Lady Health Workers vs current standard of giving 1st dose by LHWs and referral to health facility |
WHO |
Publication: Manuscript ready for submission to Lancet |
| 5 | Cost of treating severe pneumonia by Community Health Workers at household level |
10 |
Shehzad Shafqat, Shamim Qazi, Salim Sadruddin, Abdul Bari…. |
District Haripur, Pakistan Oct 2009-Oct 2010 |
Compare the cost (direct medical, direct non medical and indirect due to lost productivity and travel time) of treatment of severe pneumonia at home by LHWs to diagnosis, administration of 1st dose and referral to a health facility. |
Edinburgh School of Public Health through CHERG |
|
| 6 | Effect of new supervisory approaches on quality of care, service utilization and CHW motivation |
3 & 7 |
Seydou Doumbia, SC (Salim Sadruddin, Tanya Guenther) JHU and UNICEF… |
Two districts each in Malawi and Mali Oct 2010- Sept 2013 |
The study will compare a new supervision approach to the current system. The study will focus specifically on evaluating the effect of enhanced supervision on 1) quality of care, 2) utilization of services, and 3) CHW motivation. If possible, the cost and benefit of enhance strategy will be assessed. |
Submitted to WHO-TDR -Rejected |
|
| 7 | Effectiveness of video based competency training for CHWs |
4 |
Salim Sadruddin, Janani Vijayaraghavan, Charles Ocan, Tanya Guenther, David Marsh |
Mvolo county in South Sudan Dec 2010 June 2011 |
Compare the effect of video-taped training conducted in non medical setting on trainee competence to training in a health facility involving live clinical cases. Will measure competencies post test and persistence over time. |
Nested within CIDA |
|
| 9 | Topic to be decided, probably related to training and/or supervision |
Ethiopia |
UNICEF, SC/Italy ($100k) |
|
|||
| 10 | Topic to be decided |
Mozambique |
SC/Italy |
|
|||
| 11 | CCM of SAM study |
Can CHWs deliver an integrated model of care that includes the identification and treatment of SAM and childhood illness and preventative action at community level |
Bangladesh 2009-2010 |
Pepsico- Foundation |
Presentation: National level presentation in October 2010 in Dhaka, will be presented at Tufts University conference June 2011, and other technical meetings TBD Publication: Draft final report has been prepared. Manuscrips/articles to be prepared in 2011 Q2 and Q3
|
||
| 12 | CCM of MAM and SAM study |
Can CHWs deliver an integrated model of care that includes the identification and treatment of SAM, MAM and childhood illness as well as the delivery of key preventative actions |
Kate Sadler, Dr. Mothabbir, Erica Khetran, C Tanner, P Harrigan |
Bangladesh 2011 (12 months) |
To compare the effectiveness of treatment of MAM provided by CHWs with international standards 2. To estimate the cost-effectiveness of treatment of MAM provided by CHWs ; 3. To estimate the coverage of treatment of MAM provided by CHWs and 4To estimate the impact of a program that addresses MAM on the incidence of SAM. |
Request to GAIN (waiting) |
|
| 13 | Integration of IYCF into CMAM in Ethiopia: |
Technical consultation planned for March 29- 31st. In Addis. Final research questions(s) and research protocol to be finalized at that meeting |
Mary Lungaho NNP; Marie Mcgrath ENN; S. Butler; K. Bolles; P. Harrigan; (K. Lapping) |
Ethiopia 24 months: 6 months planning phase Jan to June 2011: implementation study phase July-June 2012; and analysis and documentation July to Dec 2012 |
This Alive & Thrive supported study project seeks to clarify operational questions raised including questions around staff roles and responsibilities, skills and training required, new and/or revised tools needed, implications on existing responsibilities within CMAM, number and types of IYCF contact points, additive effects of one versus three contacts (action-oriented groups, support groups, home visits), and necessary changes to CMAM M&E reflecting IYCF-CMAM process and outcome indicators. |
Gates A&T ( $500,000) |
|
| # | Title | CCM Priority Global Research Question(s) | Principle Investigator(s) | Settings and Time-Frame | Design | Donor | Presentation (dates) or Publication (citation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cluster Randomized Trial of Community Case Management of Severe Pneumonia with Oral Amoxicillin in Children 2-59 Months of Age |
21 |
Salim Sadruddin, Abdul Bari, Amanullah Khan, (SC) Shamim Qazi (WHO), Don Thea (BU) et al. |
District Haripur, Pakistan 2007-2011 |
Cluster randomized trial to compare the effect of treatment of severe pneumonia with amoxicillin by Lady Health Workers vs current standard of giving 1st dose by LHWs and referral to health facility |
WHO, USAID |
Publication:
Lancet, in press
|
| 2 | Feasibility and Effectiveness of an Integrated Community Health Worker – Trained Traditional Birth Attendant Team on the Delivery and Use of Treatments for Infections among Children 0-59 Months of Age in Lufwanyama District, Copperbelt Province, Zambia |
27, 31 |
Kojo Yeboah-Antwi (BU), David Marsh (SC) |
Lufwanyama, Zambia 2010-2010 |
Before-after HH survey to measure use of interventions; longitudinal measures of teaming, the domains of which informed by formative research; summative FGD and KII to explore acceptability of teaming |
USAID and Crown Family Philanthropies |
Publication: Manuscript for "teaming" formative research in preparation |
| 3 | Access to Case Management for Childhood Illness: Worse Than We Thought |
6 |
Tanya Guenther, Salim Sadruddin, David Marsh et al. (SC) |
Lufwanyama, Zambia; Malawi; and Mali 2011-2012 |
Measuring geographic, temporal, seasonal, cultural, and security barriers plus availability of case management and drugs in communities supposedly within MoH-defined access |
Nested within CIDA and CS-25 |
Presentation: Montreux HSR 11/14/10 |
| 4 | Implementation Research Embedded in Integrated Community Case Management (iCCM) Program |
How to improve iCCM routine and episodic monitoring systems using the iCCM Benchmarks indicators, with the ultimate goal of improving the effectiveness of iCCM programming through better data |
Kate Gilroy (JHU), Eric Starbuck (SC), Tanya Guenther, Hamadoun Sangho (Mali); Angella Mtimuni (Malawi) |
Malawi and Mali 2011-2013 |
1) Conduct desk reviews of available data and indicators; 2) adapted data quality audit; 3) Prioritize data needs for program management; 4) Implement innovative approaches to collection; 5) Document the feasibility, costs and quality of innovative approaches |
USAID |
|
| 5 | Factors related to performance and retention of CHWs and identification of the most appropriate set of solutions to increase CHW satisfaction and motivation |
1, 7 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2011 |
1) systematic reviews of literature, 2) landscape analysis of projects and project reports, 3) desk reviews of in-country program experiences, 4) Stakeholder interviews |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
Publication: Upcoming manuscripts: "Interventions to improve motivation and retention of community health workers delivering ICCM: stakeholder perceptions and priorities" and "Landscape analysis of mHealth approaches for increased performance and retention of community health workers" |
| 6 | Feasibility and acceptability of community and technology supported motivation for performance and motivation of CHWs. |
1,7 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2012 |
FGDs and KI interviews with 1) MOH stakeholders, 2) CHWs, 3) Community members, 4) CHW supervisors, 5) District Health Teams |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 7 | Behavioural factors among CHWs and their supervisors and important socio-cultural factors that influence CHW motivation and satisfaction, including the role of community engagement and recognition |
1,6,7 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Zelee Hill (UCL), Daniel Strachan (UCL), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2012 |
FGDs and KI interviews with 1) MOH stakeholders, 2) CHWs, 3) Community members, 4) CHW supervisors, 5) District Health Teams |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 8 | Community uptake of ICCM with respect to community members' acceptability and the perceived quality and cost of ICCM |
26,27 |
Agnes Nanyonjo (MC), Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Göran Tomson (KI), Fred Makumbi (MUSPH) |
Uganda 2011-2013 |
1) structured questionnaires with Caretakers before and after ICCM implementation 2) FGDs with caretakers, 3) case-control study on perceived care received from health facility versus CHWs |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 9 | Positive group identity among CHWs and its effect on motivation to perform and actual performance |
1,7 |
Daniel Strachan (UCL), Zelee Hill (UCL), Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC) |
Uganda 2012-2013 |
In-depth interviews with CHWs, record reviews and case scenarios for performance assessment |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 10 | Effectiveness of community supported motivation versus technology supported motivation versus standard ICCM implementation for Improved Performance and Retention of CHWs |
1,6,8,30 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2014 |
Randomized controlled trial with outcome measures: 1) proportion of children appropriately treated, 2) motivation scores, 3) attrition rate |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 11 | Financial and economic costs of community supported motivation, technology supported motivation and standard ICCM implementation to motivate and retain CHWs |
10 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2011-2014 |
Randomized controlled trial to assess incremental cost of the inSCALE innovation package(s) – (overall and per episode of treatment) |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 12 | Financial and economic costs of the implementation of ICCM in Uganda and Mozambique |
10 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2014 |
Collection of costs of the ICCM implementation (overall and per episode of care) based on MoH delivery costs: |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 13 | Cost-effectiveness of ICCM implementation at scale-up |
10 |
Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM), Zelee Hill (UCL) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2014 |
Costs per LYG and DALY averted |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 14 | Opportunity cost-value of volunteering for the CHWs in relation to SES and other economic characteristics, population characteristics and motivation |
10 |
Frida Kasteng (LSHTM), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2014 |
Collection of costs of the ICCM implementation (overall and per episode of care) based on MoH delivery costs: |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 15 | Treatment seeking behavior and costs of childhood illness in relation to socio-economic status (SES) - exploring the demands and/or benefits that ICCM brings to different social groups |
10,27,37 |
Frida Kasteng (LSHTM), Anna Vassal (LSHTM), Karin Källander (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), Sylvia Meek (MC), Betty Kirkwood (LSHTM) |
Uganda and Mozambique 2009-2014 |
Before and after HH surveys collecting information on treatment seeking for diarrhea, pneumonia and malaria across different groups of SES |
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation |
|
| 16 | Feasibility of mobile phone reporting of patient data by CHWs |
15 |
Helen Counihan (MC). Geoffrey Namara (MC), James Tibenderana (MC), James Ssekitooleko (MC) |
Uganda 2009-2012 |
Pilot study in one district of Uganda where 250 CHWs are reporting ICCM data using mobile phones |
CIDA |
|